Luigi Mangione’s defense attorneys have raised serious allegations against Manhattan prosecutors in a recent court filing. They claim that prosecutors unlawfully obtained Mangione’s medical records from his insurance provider, Aetna, without a court order or Mangione’s consent, violating his privacy rights under the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA). The defense argues that the Manhattan District Attorney’s office used a “false and fraudulent” subpoena to pressure Aetna into releasing 120 pages of medical information, including diagnoses and specific complaints.
The legal team asserts that the prosecutors’ actions intentionally violated Mangione’s doctor-patient privilege and bypassed legal procedures. They are calling for an evidentiary hearing and are seeking the possibility of having the charges against Mangione dismissed. They further claim that the information obtained was irrelevant to the case and was falsely linked to a court date that never existed.
In response, the Manhattan District Attorney’s office confirmed that only limited information was requested from Aetna, but the insurer mistakenly sent additional records. The office stated that the extra materials were deleted promptly upon discovery and that they had informed both the defense and the court.
Mangione, who faces charges in both state and federal court in connection with the December 4 shooting death of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson in Manhattan, has pleaded not guilty to all charges. His defense team is also fighting for a reduction in his conditions, including allowing him to attend court without handcuffs or body armor.
At the heart of the case, Mangione’s attorneys are challenging the legal methods used to gather evidence against him, particularly focusing on the alleged medical privacy violation. The outcome of this case could have significant implications for future legal proceedings and privacy concerns in criminal cases.
Mangione, currently held in the Metropolitan Detention Center in Brooklyn, is facing multiple charges, including first-degree murder, terrorism, and federal firearms offenses. His next court appearance is set for September 16, 2025.
In other news of Read about the scrutiny Astronomer CEO Andy Byron faces after the Coldplay kiss cam incident
