The review offers a nuanced perspective on Imtiaz Ali’s portrayal of the legendary Punjabi singer, Amar Singh Chamkila, in his latest film. It delves into the complexities of Chamkila’s life, his impact on society, and the challenges of translating his story to the screen.
The review acknowledges Diljit Dosanjh’s passionate portrayal of Chamkila but notes that the film falls short in capturing the essence of his music and persona. Despite the film’s attempt to humanize Chamkila, it is criticized for lacking the necessary depth and passion expected from such a character-driven narrative.
Moreover, the review highlights the film’s exploration of societal hypocrisy and its relevance in today’s context. It applauds the narrative structure that alternates between past and present, creating a poignant reflection on Chamkila’s legacy and society’s response to his artistry.
However, the review also points out the film’s shortcomings, particularly in its inability to fully engage with the profound relationship between Chamkila and his music. It suggests that the film’s attempt to hold a mirror to society exposes deeper societal fractures but falls short of delivering a cohesive and impactful narrative.
Overall, the review gives the film a rating of 3 out of 5, acknowledging its ambition but ultimately deeming it only partially successful in achieving its goals. It concludes by cautioning that Amar Singh Chamkila may not be suitable for audiences seeking a typical family entertainer.
